BaseballHistorical AnalysisSteroid Era

The Rise and Fall of the Home Run

Tracing the evolution of power hitting from Babe Ruth through the steroid era and beyond.

I've loaded the Lahman baseball database. Can you show me how home run hitting has evolved over baseball history?
Great question. Let me pull the average home runs per player per season from 1920 to 2015. This will show us the major shifts in power hitting across different eras.
You can see several distinct eras here. The jump in the 1920s is the "Babe Ruth revolution" - he literally changed how the game was played. Then there's the big dip in the early 1940s (World War II), followed by steady growth through the 1950s-60s. But look at that massive spike starting in the mid-1990s - that's the steroid era. Peak around 2000, then a decline after MLB implemented stricter testing in 2006.
What about the truly elite seasons? Who has hit 50 or more home runs in a single year?
The 50-homer club is one of baseball's most exclusive achievements. Let me show you the top 20 single-season performances.
The steroid era dominance is impossible to miss. Barry Bonds' 73 in 2001 is the all-time record, followed by McGwire's 70 in 1998. The top 6 seasons are ALL from 1998-2001. Babe Ruth's 60 in 1927 - which stood as the record for 34 years - is now 8th on the list. Roger Maris' 61 in 1961, which broke Ruth's record and stood until 1998, is only 7th.
Who are the career home run leaders?
Here are the top 15 all-time home run hitters.
Barry Bonds leads with 762, followed closely by Hank Aaron at 755 - Aaron held the record from 1974 until Bonds passed him in 2007. Babe Ruth is third at 714. Notice how many steroid-era players populate this list: Bonds, A-Rod, Sosa, McGwire, Palmeiro, Manny Ramirez. It's a complicated legacy - these were genuinely talented hitters who also played during an era of rampant PED use.
Can you quantify how unusual the steroid era was compared to other periods?
Absolutely. Let me count how many 50+ home run seasons occurred in each era of baseball history.
This is the smoking gun. The Steroid Era (1994-2006) produced 20 fifty-homer seasons in just 13 years. The Ruth Era (1920-1940), which includes all of Ruth's legendary seasons, produced only 8 in 21 years. The Pre-Steroid era from 1977-1993 - seventeen years - produced just 2. The statistical anomaly is undeniable.
The 1998 home run race between McGwire and Sosa was huge. Can you show how they compared?
The 1998 race was one of baseball's most dramatic moments - both players chasing Roger Maris' record of 61. Let me chart their head-to-head numbers from 1995-2002.
McGwire exploded in 1996 with 52 homers, then dealt with injuries in 1997 (23 HR in limited games). In 1998, they both went nuclear - McGwire with 70, Sosa with 66. McGwire hit 65 again in 1999, but then declined sharply. Sosa stayed more consistent, posting three consecutive 60+ seasons from 1998-2001. It was a genuine race that captivated the nation - though we now know PEDs were involved for both players.

5 visualizations generated with Dolex